CoinTracker vs Koinly Comparison

CoinTracker
CoinTracker
4.7of 5
Go to CoinTracker
vs
Koinly
Koinly
4.6of 5
Go to Koinly

Pros & Cons

CoinTracker
CoinTracker
Pros
  • Supports over 500 exchanges and wallets
  • User interface is described as very user-friendly
  • Automatic categorization of smart contracts and NFTs integrated
  • SOC 1- and SOC 2-certified security standards
  • Mobile app for iOS and Android as well as web version available
  • Free portfolio tracking without tax form download
Cons
  • Pricing structure at high transaction volumes (59 to 1,999+ USD/year) has room for improvement
  • Focus on US and English-speaking markets, German tax reports have room for improvement
  • HIFO not available as a tax method — occasionally criticized
CoinTracker Reviews
Koinly
Koinly
Pros
  • Supports over 800 exchanges and wallets
  • Simple, beginner-friendly setup is appreciated
  • Integrated DeFi, staking, and mining tracking
  • Free portfolio tracking available without payment obligation
  • Support for FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, and ACB as tax methods
Cons
  • Audit support is currently not available and is occasionally criticized
  • Pricing structure for high transaction volumes (USD 49 to 279/year) is room for improvement
  • German localization is room for improvement, with a focus on the English-speaking market
Koinly Reviews

Score Comparison

4.6Usability4.6
4.6Features4.4
4.2Fees4.0
4.1Stability4.3
4.3Support3.7

User Experiences

AI Analysis
4.7
App Store
4.4
Google Play
4.6
Trustpilot
CoinTracker
CoinTracker

According to user feedback, CoinTracker is generally described rather positively overall. Users especially appreciate that many pieces of information are bundled in one place and that the application supports tax documentation. However, some users occasionally report login issues, high costs, and individual service experiences.

Koinly
Koinly

Not enough reviews available.

This analysis is based on 385 AI-evaluated user reviews from the Apple App Store, Trustpilot, Google Play Store. The total number of reviews on the respective platforms may be higher — the platform ratings (star ratings) shown refer to all reviews available there. The ratings displayed reflect users' experiences and do not represent the website operator's own assessment. All information is provided without guarantee. As of: April 2026. This comparison does not constitute investment advice.

Features

CoinTrackerKoinly
DeFi support
Tax advisor export
FIFO method
LIFO method
API access
Mobile app
Free plan
NFT tracking
Staking tracking
Audit support
DeFi Support
Tax Advisor Export
FIFO Method
LIFO Method
API Access
Mobile App
Free Plan
NFT Tracking
Staking Tracking
Audit Support
CoinTracker
CoinTrackerHighlights
  • Real-time API and automatic wallet monitoring
  • SOC 1 and SOC 2 certification for data security
  • Tax professional portal and full-service options for comprehensive support
  • Tiered transaction limits from 100 to 250,000+
Koinly
KoinlyHighlights
  • Mobile app available for iOS and Android
  • Support for over 20 countries with country-specific tax reports
  • Live chat and email support for quick help
  • Automatic import via API and wallet addresses

Details